Search for Homes:
Search
RELO® Home Search is your direct link to real estate experts, local information, and property listings from Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® members.
Scroll through the listing previews below to find the homes that interest you. They are sorted by price from low to high. You can refine your search if necessary or get more info about a property by clicking on its image.
Search Options
Location:
Min Price:
Max Price:
Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
Property Types:
Single Family (287)
Condo (25)

Welcome to Middlebury, IN

Nestled in northeastern Elkhart County, Middlebury covers approximately 100 square miles of scenic, semi-rural landscape. The large Amish and Mennonite population impact the town with a conservative flavor. Families seeking an environment that nurtures strong traditional values in a small town setting find themselves attracted to this historic district.

Middlebury’s population is 2,000 respectively. Despite its small town size, Middlebury attracts tourists from across the nation. Visitors experience “Amish Country” and culture through specialty shops featuring crafts and fresh baked goods, scenic buggy rides, and fine Amish cuisine served at the Das Dutchman Essenhaus, Indiana’s largest restaurant. Merchants take pride in their work, offering customers quality service and products. And residents do not need to travel far to experience urban culture. The town is located near Elkhart and South Bend, two cities that offer an abundance of entertainment options.

Top industries in Middlebury include farming, manufacturing and tourism. While recreational vehicles dominate the manufacturing industry, the town is also known for its fine furniture craftsmanship and elegantly detailed Amish quilts.
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in Indiana
Elkhart County, IN
Elkhart County, Indiana, offers a mix of urban and rural living with a population of nearly 200,000. The large Amish population contributes to th... Read more
Welcome to Elkhart, IN
Located in the heart of Amish Country, Elkhart, Indiana, is the birth place of Alka Seltzer and claims to have produced more patents than any othe... Read more
About Granger, IN
Prior to 1883, the region now known as Granger, Indiana, served as a depot for Lake Huron and Chicago Railroad. The only structures that existed a... Read more
Living in Mishawaka, IN
Mishawaka, Indiana, established in 1899, is the birthplace of the Hummer (produced by AM General) and home to approximately 49,000 people. The city’... Read more
Welcome to Cassopolis, MI
The first settlers of Cassopolis were the Putnams, a small family from Indiana who took up residence in October of 1825. Their humble floorless hom... Read more
Living in Edwardsburg, MI
A Cass County village, Edwardsburg, Mich., provides a country setting in a quiet environment. This small community is located just northeast of Sout... Read more
Welcome to Goshen, IN
With an estimated population of 31,882 in 2006, Goshen, Indiana, is the county seat of Elkhart County. The neighborly, service-oriented environment... Read more
Welcome to Three Rivers, MI
In 1840 Three Rivers, Mich., was named for the three rivers—Rocky, Portage and St. Joseph River—that flow together to become one. In 1895, th... Read more
Living in Bristol, IN
A small town in Elkhart County, Bristol was founded by European settlers approximately 200 years ago. Today, Bristol looks forward to the future wit... Read more
Welcome to Sturgis, MI
Judge John Sturgis was the first settler in 1827 in the area now known as Sturgis, Mich., located in St. Joseph County. His rustic log cabin stil... Read more
Saint Joseph County, IN
Saint Joseph County is located on the southernmost bend of the St. Joseph River in northern Indiana. The river dips down into Indiana from Michigan... Read more
Cass County, MI
Cass County, Michigan, was established in 1828 during the presidency of Andrew Jackson and named after Lewis Cass who served as territorial governo... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.

Total
Sold

Median
Price

Average
Price

Middlebury, IN14$143,750$159,630
home sale data for other nearby cities
Bremen, IN1$149,062$149,062
Bristol, IN19$100,408$132,077
Cassopolis, MI16$58,000$64,125
Colon, MI1$246,425$246,425
Constantine, MI2$83,500$83,500
Dowagiac, MI13$88,000$94,669
Edwardsburg, MI26$102,538$149,915
Elkhart, IN167$86,988$102,239
Goshen, IN91$106,085$112,676
Granger, IN56$187,621$217,527
Jones, MI2$27,000$27,000
Marcellus, MI4$61,879$61,879
Millersburg, IN6$132,556$134,735
Mishawaka, IN104$81,173$97,092
Nappanee, IN17$109,968$120,447
New Paris, IN6$117,444$110,012
Niles, MI63$89,800$115,279
Osceola, IN33$124,000$123,489
Schoolcraft, MI20$126,250$143,551
Shipshewana, IN4$116,100$111,300
South Bend, IN206$79,912$97,294
Syracuse, IN1$146,372$146,372
Union, MI14$85,000$160,414
Vandalia, MI2$79,000$79,000
Wakarusa, IN5$122,187$142,289
Show Statistics for:

Population

Total Population3,365
Population Density915 Persons/Sq. Mile
Female Population1,675
Male Population1,690
Population Change since 1990↑ 40% Increase
Population Change since 2000↑ 14% Increase

Colleges

Nearest 2-Year Public CollegeGlen Oaks Community College
Distance19 miles
Nearest 4-Year Public CollegeGoshen College
Distance10 miles

Households and Income

Total Number of Households1,164
Family Households907
Average Family Size3.42
Average Household Income$76,854
Median Household Income$62,467
Income Change since 1990↑ 693978% Increase
Income Change since 2000↑ 14% Increase

Crime Rates Compared to National Average

The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk.
Total Crime Risk0.70
Crime Risk (County)0.68
Personal Crime Risk (County)0.77
Murder Crime Risk (County)0.93
Rape Crime Risk (County)0.59
Robbery Crime Risk (County)0.84
Assault Crime Risk (County)1.24
Property Crime Risk (County)1.29
Burglary Crime Risk (County)1.52
Larceny Crime Risk (County)0.73
Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County)0.52

Climate

Average July High Temperature84.5 °F
Average January Low Temperature17.0 °F
Annual Precipitation36.6 inches
Air Pollution Index87% of National Average

Miscellaneous

Sales Tax Rate7.00%
Nearest AirportSouth Bend Regional
Distance32 miles
Nearest Major Sports TeamSouth Bend Silver Hawks (a)
Distance28 miles
Show Schools in:
show school on mapPin Schools to Map
Grade Levels:
pin all schools

Grades: 7 - 8

Northridge Middle School56691 Northridge Dr

Grades: 9 - 12

Northridge High School56779 Northridge Dr

Grades: K - 6

Middlebury Elementary School432 S Main Street
Orchard View Elementary School56734 Northridge Dr

Grades: Other

Heritage Intermediate School56647 N Ridge Dr
Show Local Businesses in:

ART AND MUSEUMS

Middlebury Community Hstrcl301 Bristol Ave

BANKS

1st Source Bank801 Wayne St # 4
First State Bank Of Middlebury111 S Main St
Lake City Bank712 Wayne St
Peoples Federal Savings Bank420 N Main St # 7

EMERGENCY SERVICES

Middlebury Fire Dept117 N Main St
Middlebury Police Dept418 N Main St
Middlebury Twp Fire Dept117 N Main St

GOLF

Meadow Valley Golf Club57600 State Road 13
Sims Oak Hills Golf Course11522 State Road 120

LIBRARIES - PUBLIC

Middlebury Community Library101 E Winslow St

MISC ATTRACTIONS

Business Motorcoach TravelPo Box 67
One Stop Video Shop129 Orpha Dr

PLACE OF WORSHIP

Crystal Valley Missionary Chr233 Us Highway 20
Fairhaven Am Church13513 County Road 4
Faith Baptist Church110 N Brown St
First Mennonite Church203 E Lawrence St
First United Methodist Church301 S Main St
Forks Mennonite Church11435 W 025 S
Griner Mennonite Church12418 County Road 20
Living Stones Chrstn Fllwshp11020 County Road 4

Instant Cost of Living Comparison

For us to calculate a cost of living report, please provide us with the zip code where you currently live.
Enter Your Zip Code
Compare additional locations
The following company is available to assist you in searching for property listings in or near Middlebury
Cressy & Everett Real Estate
8 offices | 146 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Mortgage Pre-Approval, Photos/Virtual Tours