Search for Homes:
Search
RELO® Home Search is your direct link to real estate experts, local information, and property listings from Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® members.
Scroll through the listing previews below to find the homes that interest you. They are sorted by price from low to high. You can refine your search if necessary or get more info about a property by clicking on its image.
142 listings found within of Bay Shore, New York
$
$$$
Search Options
Location:
Min Price:
Max Price:
Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
Property Types:
Single Family (122)
Rental (9)
Condo (7)
Land/Lot (2)
Multi Family (1)
Other (1)

Welcome to Bay Shore, NY

Bay Shore is located on the Great South Bay of Long Island and is a large sprawling town. It was purchased from the Indians in 1701. The village is a quintessential small town with the qualities of a close community. It bustles with shops, boutiques, artists, craftspeople, and multicultural restaurants. Large estates from Long Island’s golden era populate the area near the bay. It is a train ride to Manhattan and a boat or car ride to Fire Island.
Contributed by:
Netter Real Estate
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in New York
About West Islip, NY
West Islip, NY is hamlet in the Town of Islip along Long Island’s Spectacular South Shore. It’s about 45 miles east of New York City, which is clos... Read more
Welcome to North Babylon, NY
North Babylon, NY is a hamlet in the Town of Babylon and has an interesting history. Originally, North Babylon was comprised of a few farms. It the... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.

Total
Sold

Median
Price

Average
Price

Bay Shore, NY101$197,700$246,333
home sale data for other nearby cities
Bayberry Point, NY23$291,000$316,224
Brentwood, NY72$165,000$203,074
Brightwaters, NY6$534,785$539,512
Central Islip, NY87$178,713$181,994
Deer Park, NY39$275,000$512,096
Deer Wells, NY25$428,000$558,591
East Islip, NY16$295,000$298,656
Great River, NY3$500,000$518,167
Heer Park, NY64$284,000$280,853
Islandia, NY9$246,000$251,167
Islip, NY23$291,000$316,224
Islip Terrace, NY14$333,850$300,864
Kismet, NY101$197,700$246,333
N Babylon, NY33$318,000$282,580
North Babylon, NY33$318,000$282,580
Oak Beach, NY16$442,000$481,469
Oakdale, NY14$339,250$360,921
Saltaire, NY101$197,700$246,333
W Babylon, NY59$273,000$272,941
W Islip, NY38$332,500$375,934
West Babylon, NY59$273,000$272,941
West Bay Shore, NY101$197,700$246,333
West Islip, NY38$332,500$375,934
Wheatley Heights, NY27$150,000$169,535
Wyandanch, NY27$150,000$169,535
Show Statistics for:

Population

Total Population25,066
Population Density4,929 Persons/Sq. Mile
Female Population12,692
Male Population12,373
Population Change since 1990↑ 17% Increase
Population Change since 2000↑ 4% Increase

Colleges

Nearest 2-Year Public CollegeLong Island Business Institute
Distance8 miles
Nearest 4-Year Public CollegeDowling College
Distance6 miles

Households and Income

Total Number of Households8,235
Family Households5,430
Average Family Size3.76
Average Household Income$90,780
Median Household Income$65,356
Income Change since 1990↑ 43763% Increase
Income Change since 2000↑ 30% Increase

Crime Rates Compared to National Average

The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk.
Total Crime Risk0.37
Crime Risk (County)0.26
Personal Crime Risk (County)0.29
Murder Crime Risk (County)0.18
Rape Crime Risk (County)0.25
Robbery Crime Risk (County)0.25
Assault Crime Risk (County)0.45
Property Crime Risk (County)0.38
Burglary Crime Risk (County)0.64
Larceny Crime Risk (County)0.25
Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County)0.43

Climate

Average July High Temperature83.2 °F
Average January Low Temperature22.6 °F
Annual Precipitation46.5 inches
Air Pollution Index105% of National Average

Miscellaneous

Sales Tax Rate8.63%
Nearest AirportLong Island Macarthur
Distance9 miles
Nearest Major Sports TeamNew York Islanders
Distance18 miles
Show Schools in:
show school on mapPin Schools to Map
Filter by District:
Grade Levels:
pin all schools

Grades: 7 - 8

Bay Shore Middle School393 Brook Ave
West Middle School2030 Udall Rd

Grades: 9 - 12

Bay Shore High School155 3rd Ave

Grades: K - 6

Brook Avenue Elementary School45 Brook Ave
Hemlock Park Elementary School19 Hemlock Dr
Oak Park Elementary School775 Wisconsin Ave
Southwest Elementary School1095 Joselson Ave

Grades: Other

Bay Shore Christian School211 Bay Shore Rd
Ebenezer Christian Academy69 Wisconsin Ave
Fifth Avenue School217 5th Ave
Gardiner Manor School125 Wohseepee Dr
Heritage Christian Academy1380 5th Ave
Mary G Clarkson School1415 E 3rd Ave
South Country School885 Hampshire Rd
St Patrick SchoolMontauk Hwy
St Peter's By The Sea Day School500 S Country Rd
Show Local Businesses in:

BANKS

Astoria Federal Savings & Loan300 E Main St
Bank Of New York Mellon380 E Main St
Capital One Bank1701 Sunrise Hwy # A16b
Capital One Bank2 E Main St
Chase1650 5th Ave
Chase537 E Main St
Chase840 Sunrise Hwy
Citibank77 E Main St
Hsbc Bank430 E Main St
New York Community Bank533 E Main St
Republic National Bank Of Ny1241 Sunrise Hwy
Roslyn Savings Bank130 E Main St
Roslyn Savings Bank1905 Sunrise Hwy

EMERGENCY SERVICES

Bay Shore Fire Dept195 5th Ave
Saltaire Village Public Safety18 Bay Prom St

GOLF

Southward Ho Country Club601 W Montauk Hwy

GOVERNMENT OFFICES

Suffolk County Police Dept1630 5th Ave

HOSPITALS

Southside Health Institute301 E Main St
Southside Hospital301 E Main St
Southside Hospital Psychiatric301 E Main St

PLACE OF WORSHIP

Abundant Life Chrstn Fllwshp68 Redington St

Instant Cost of Living Comparison

For us to calculate a cost of living report, please provide us with the zip code where you currently live.
Enter Your Zip Code
Compare additional locations
4 Real Estate companies have been found with properties in or near Bay Shore
 Coach Real Estate Associates
Coach Real Estate Associates
23 offices | 620 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Photos/Virtual Tours, Multimedia
Search All MLS Listings at Coach Real Estate Associates
View Open House Schedule (265 properties)
Netter Real Estate
Netter Real Estate
1 offices | 57 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Photos/Virtual Tours
Search All MLS Listings at Netter Real Estate
View Open House Schedule (12 properties)
Laffey Fine Homes
Laffey Fine Homes
12 offices | 550 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Mortgage Pre-Approval, Photos/Virtual Tours
Search All MLS Listings at Laffey Fine Homes
View Open House Schedule (105 properties)
Lynda Baker Realty
Lynda Baker Realty
3 offices | 69 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Mortgage Pre-Approval, Photos/Virtual Tours
Search All MLS Listings at Lynda Baker Realty
View Open House Schedule (23 properties)