Search for Homes:
Search
RELO® Home Search is your direct link to real estate experts, local information, and property listings from Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® members.
Scroll through the listing previews below to find the homes that interest you. They are sorted by price from low to high. You can refine your search if necessary or get more info about a property by clicking on its image.
118 listings found within of Montauk, New York
Montauk, NY
Property at Montauk 11954, Montauk, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,625,000
Amagansett, NY
Property at Amagansett 11930, Amagansett, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,650,000
Montauk, NY
Property at Montauk 11954, Montauk, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,695,000
Montauk, NY
Property in Montauk, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,695,000
Amagansett, NY
Property at Amagansett 11930, Amagansett, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,700,000
Amagansett, NY
Property at Amagansett 11930, Amagansett, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,775,000
Amagansett, NY
Property at Amagansett 11930, Amagansett, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,795,000
Amagansett, NY
Property in Amagansett, NY For Sale
View Details
$1,795,000
$
$$$
Search Options
Location:
Min Price:
Max Price:
Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:

Welcome to Montauk, NY

Montauk is a hamlet within the town of East Hampton, located on the south shore of Long Island in Suffolk County, NY. When the first generations of European settlers arrived on Long Island, they leased the area of Montauk from the native Algonquian Indians as pasture land for their livestock. In 1686, East Hampton settlers purchased the land outright, and Montauk became home to the first cattle ranch in the United States. In the summer months, more than 1500 cattle from all over Long Island were driven into the area from as far as 70 miles away. At the turn of the 18th century, there were three permanent residences; First House, Second House, and Third House, named so for the order in which someone would pass them when riding out. After the state of New York joined the Union, President George Washington established a Coast Guard station in Montauk with the construction of the well known Montauk Lighthouse in 1797. Until the late 19th century, the lighthouse and three residences were the only structures in Montauk. As New York City began to grow in the 19th century, so did the East End of Long Island. In the early 1900’s, elite New Yorkers began to purchase land in Montauk on which to build summer homes, and thus began Montauk’s tourist industry. The region’s natural beauty—its acres of undisturbed land, miles of white sandy beaches, and rolling surf of the Atlantic Ocean—still attract thousands of people from all over the world today. Montauk has six state parks that offer everything from hiking to camping to leisurely picnicking. Montauk is also a major destination for commercial and recreational fishermen, the Montauk Harbors being the busiest in the state of New York.

Being at the easternmost tip of Long Island, Montauk playfully advertises itself as “the last resort,” and takes great pride in its laid back beachy atmosphere. Perhaps it is this aspect that brings not only tourists, but many new residents to the community. Currently, the year-round population of Montauk is at approximately 4,000. The people of Montauk take great care to preserve the town’s charm and character by not allowing the area to become overly-commercialized. East Hampton town zoning regulations prevent chain stores from taking over; in fact, there are no chain restaurants, retail stores, or hotels in Montauk, which means that there’s always something special around every corner in Montauk.

© 2008 Reliance Relocation Services, Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Contributed by:
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in New York
Montauk, New York Real Estate Offers a Variety of Housing Options
For those who want to relocate to Montauk and take part in this unique, fun-loving community, the Montauk real estate offers a variety of housin... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.

Total
Sold

Median
Price

Average
Price

Montauk, NY41$750,000$1,219,702
home sale data for other nearby cities
Amagansett, NY2$4,261,250$4,261,250
Bay Point, NY70$849,500$1,161,541
Bridgehampton, NY2$1,817,500$1,817,500
East Hampton, NY165$710,000$1,724,315
East Marion, NY9$450,000$579,030
Greenport, NY25$430,000$540,152
Groton, CT212$172,500$224,967
Groton Long Point, CT212$172,500$224,967
Mystic, CT82$272,500$312,755
N Haven, NY70$849,500$1,161,541
New London, CT240$123,900$143,879
Niantic, CT156$239,500$305,700
Noank, CT212$172,500$224,967
North Haven, NY70$849,500$1,161,541
Orient, NY6$585,000$663,767
Orient Point, NY6$585,000$663,767
Pawcatuck, CT66$233,750$272,156
Redwood, NY15$71,000$114,603
Sag Harbor, NY70$849,500$1,161,541
Sagaponack, NY1$1,425,000$1,425,000
Shelter Island, NY4$923,750$821,125
Stonington, CT81$299,900$420,656
Watch Hill, RI264$250,526$399,223
Water Mill, NY28$2,000,000$2,753,089
Watermill, NY28$2,000,000$2,753,089
Show Statistics for:

Population

Total Population27,669
Population Density4,996 Persons/Sq. Mile
Female Population14,097
Male Population13,572
Population Change since 1990↓ 3% Decrease
Population Change since 2000↑ 8% Increase

Colleges

Nearest 2-Year Public CollegeThree Rivers Community College
Distance14 miles
Nearest 4-Year Public CollegeUnited States Coast Guard Acad
Distance1 miles

Households and Income

Total Number of Households11,495
Family Households5,757
Average Family Size3.02
Average Household Income$54,130
Median Household Income$41,481
Income Change since 1990↑ 58% Increase
Income Change since 2000↑ 22% Increase

Crime Rates Compared to National Average

The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk.
Total Crime Risk1.34
Crime Risk (County)0.44
Personal Crime Risk (County)0.49
Murder Crime Risk (County)0.31
Rape Crime Risk (County)0.89
Robbery Crime Risk (County)0.31
Assault Crime Risk (County)0.35
Property Crime Risk (County)0.37
Burglary Crime Risk (County)0.31
Larceny Crime Risk (County)0.54
Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County)0.22

Climate

Average July High Temperature80.7 °F
Average January Low Temperature20.0 °F
Annual Precipitation48.7 inches
Air Pollution Index109% of National Average

Miscellaneous

Sales Tax Rate6.00%
Nearest AirportGroton-new London
Distance3 miles
Nearest Major Sports TeamConnecticut Sun
Distance10 miles
Show Schools in:
show school on mapPin Schools to Map
Grade Levels:
pin all schools

Grades: K - 8

Montauk Public School50 S Dorset Rd
Show Local Businesses in:

AIR TRAVEL

Montauk AirportE Lake Dr

ART AND MUSEUMS

Montauk Lighthouse Museum2000 Montauk Hwy

BANKS

Bank Of New York MellonMontauk Hwy
Bridgehampton National Bank1 The Plaza
Chase731 Montauk Hwy
Suffolk County National Bank15 W Lake Dr
Suffolk County National Bank746 Montauk Hwy

EMERGENCY SERVICES

Montauk Fire Dist12 Flamingo Ave
Montauk Police Precinct52 S Embassy St

LIBRARIES - PUBLIC

Montauk Library871 Montauk Hwy

PLACE OF WORSHIP

Montauk Community ChurchS Etna Ave
Robert Church Assoc IncLake Dr E
St Therese Of Lisieux67 Essex St

POST OFFICES

Us Post OfficeS Edison Dr
Us Post OfficeS Edision

Instant Cost of Living Comparison

For us to calculate a cost of living report, please provide us with the zip code where you currently live.
Enter Your Zip Code
Compare additional locations