Search for Homes:
Search
RELO® Home Search is your direct link to real estate experts, local information, and property listings from Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® members.
Scroll through the listing previews below to find the homes that interest you. They are sorted by price from low to high. You can refine your search if necessary or get more info about a property by clicking on its image.
Search Options
Location:
Min Price:
Max Price:
Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
Property Types:
Single Family (47)
Land/Lot (4)
Condo (2)
Rental (2)

The Three Villages, New York

Located in the geographic midpoint of Long Island, the Three Villages—Setauket, Old Field, and Stony Brook—are situated approximately 60 miles east of Manhattan and 60 miles west of Montauk. The area’s charm and natural beauty is intertwined with a rich history that is evident from the moment one steps foot in the community.

Originally founded in 1655, the village of Setauket was the first settlement in what is now the Town of Brookhaven. Purchased directly from the Setalcott Indians (wherefrom the area derives its name), the land is lavish with engaging historical sites, including The Long Island Museum of American Art, History & Carriages, Stony Brook Village Center, Old Field Lighthouse, and more. Housing in the area is dated anywhere from 300 to 5 years old, giving home buyers varying degrees of price and diversity. The township is rife with history, allowing residents a small-town feel with a strong close-knit community while still providing ample avenues for cultural recreation and relaxation.

The scenic district is host to many seasonal community and family events. Fall activities include the annual Scarecrow Competition and Halloween Celebration as well as Gallery North Outdoor Art Show. The winter calendar includes the Electric Light Holiday Parade and Tree Lighting Festival, and summer brings with it a village-wide Summer Beach BBQ.

Dozens of beautiful and pristine parks, walking trails, and beaches comprise the Three Village area, including the Avalon Park Nature Preserve, Setauket Mill Pond & Frank Melville Memorial Park overlooking the Conscience Bay marshlands, and West Meadow Beach.

The Three Village Central School District is celebrated for its excellence in education and is composed of five elementary schools, two junior highs, and Ward Melville High School. Between 1956 and 1968, local philanthropist Ward Melville donated 600 acres of land to New York State, which is now the center of the main campus of State University of New York (SUNY) at Stony Brook. As the university expanded, additional land was taken by the state for the university hospital and medical school. The campus now includes 123 buildings stretching across 1,100 acres with annexes in nearby Southampton as well as Manhattan.
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in New York
Welcome to Setauket, NY
Setauket, NY is located on the North Shore of Long Island, New York and encompasses both Setauket and East Setauket. This town is included in th... Read more
Welcome to Port Jefferson, NY
Port Jefferson is located on the beautiful north shore of Long Island, New York. Approximately 56 miles east of Manhattan. This small town i... Read more
Welcome to Stony Brook, NY
The town of Stony Brook is situated on the North Shore of Long Island, New York. Centrally located on Long Island Stony Brook is approximately 6... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.

Total
Sold

Median
Price

Average
Price

Setauket, NY36$431,250$517,798
home sale data for other nearby cities
Belle Terre, NY16$367,500$407,313
Centereach, NY46$295,000$313,379
E Setauket, NY36$431,250$517,798
East Setauket, NY36$431,250$517,798
Flowerfield, NY25$428,000$558,591
Head of the Harbor, NY58$419,465$481,257
Lake Grove, NY24$306,000$332,873
Mount Sinai, NY22$392,000$398,345
Mt Sinai, NY22$392,000$398,345
Mt. Sinai, NY22$392,000$398,345
Nesconset, NY18$367,000$389,383
Nissequogue, NY25$428,000$558,591
Old Field, NY36$431,250$517,798
Poquott, NY36$431,250$517,798
Port Jefferson, NY16$367,500$407,313
Port Jefferson Station, NY60$302,600$306,594
Prt Jefferson, NY16$367,500$407,313
Prt Jefferson station, NY44$279,000$269,969
Pt Jefferson station, NY16$367,500$407,313
Saint James, NY75$428,000$558,591
Selden, NY37$235,850$230,936
South Setauket, NY46$295,000$313,379
Stony Brook, NY33$413,000$422,672
Strongs Neck, NY36$431,250$517,798
Terryville, NY44$279,000$269,969
Show Statistics for:

Population

Total Population12,218
Population Density6,365 Persons/Sq. Mile
Female Population6,170
Male Population6,047
Population Change since 1990↑ 16% Increase
Population Change since 2000↑ 4% Increase

Colleges

Nearest 2-Year Public CollegeIsland Drafting And Tech Inst
Distance3 miles
Nearest 4-Year Public CollegeFarmingdale Suny
Distance4 miles

Households and Income

Total Number of Households3,782
Family Households2,880
Average Family Size3.81
Average Household Income$87,008
Median Household Income$70,345
Income Change since 1990↑ 167388% Increase
Income Change since 2000↑ 18% Increase

Crime Rates Compared to National Average

The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk.
Total Crime Risk0.42
Crime Risk (County)0.26
Personal Crime Risk (County)0.29
Murder Crime Risk (County)0.18
Rape Crime Risk (County)0.25
Robbery Crime Risk (County)0.25
Assault Crime Risk (County)0.45
Property Crime Risk (County)0.38
Burglary Crime Risk (County)0.64
Larceny Crime Risk (County)0.25
Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County)0.43

Climate

Average July High Temperature81.0 °F
Average January Low Temperature24.2 °F
Annual Precipitation43.0 inches
Air Pollution Index107% of National Average

Miscellaneous

Sales Tax Rate8.63%
Nearest AirportLong Island Macarthur
Distance16 miles
Nearest Major Sports TeamNew York Islanders
Distance11 miles
Show Schools in:
show school on mapPin Schools to Map
Grade Levels:
pin all schools

Grades: 9 - 12

Paul J Gelinas Junior High School25 Mud Rd
Ward Melville Senior High School380 Old Town Rd

Grades: K - 6

Arrowhead Elementary School62 Arrowhead Ln
Minnesauke Elementary School21 High Gate Dr
Nassakeag Elementary School490 Pond Path
Setauket Elementary School134 Main St

Grades: Other

Alternatives For Children14 Research Way
Laurel Hill School201 Old Town Rd
Show Local Businesses in:

ART AND MUSEUMS

Three Village Historic Society93 N Country Rd

BANKS

Apple Bank For Savings10 Route 25a
Capital One Bank61 Route 25a
State Bank234 Route 25a

EMERGENCY SERVICES

Old Field Village Constables207 Old Field Rd

GOLF

St George's Golf & Country Clb134 Lower Sheep Pasture Rd

LIBRARIES - PUBLIC

Emma Clark Memorial Library120 Main St

PLACE OF WORSHIP

Bethel Ame Church33 Christian Ave
Caroline Church Of Brookhaven1 Dyke Rd
Presbyterian Church-setauket5 Caroline Ave
Setauket United Methodist Chr160 Main St
St James Roman Catholic Church429 Route 25a
Unitarian Fellowship380 Nicolls Rd

POST OFFICES

Us Post Office101 Main St
2 Real Estate companies have been found with properties in or near Setauket
Shea & Sanders Real Estate
2 offices | 22 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Mortgage Pre-Approval, Photos/Virtual Tours