Min Price: $1 $50,000 $75,000 $100,000 $125,000 $150,000 $175,000 $200,000 $225,000 $250,000 $275,000 $300,000 $350,000 $400,000 $450,000 $500,000 $550,000 $600,000 $650,000 $700,000 $750,000 $800,000 $850,000 $900,000 $950,000 $1,000,000 $2,000,000 $3,000,000 $4,000,000 $5,000,000 $6,000,000 $7,000,000 $8,000,000 $9,000,000 Max Price: $5,000 $50,000 $75,000 $100,000 $125,000 $150,000 $175,000 $200,000 $225,000 $250,000 $275,000 $300,000 $350,000 $400,000 $450,000 $500,000 $550,000 $600,000 $650,000 $700,000 $750,000 $800,000 $850,000 $900,000 $950,000 $1,000,000 $2,000,000 $3,000,000 $4,000,000 $5,000,000 $6,000,000 $7,000,000 $8,000,000 $9,000,000 Bedrooms: at least 1 at least 2 at least 3 at least 4 at least 5 Bathrooms: at least 1 at least 2 at least 3 at least 4 at least 5
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in New York
Living in North Haven, NY
Just outside the historic village of Sag Harbor, North Haven links the South Fork via the South Ferry to Shelter Island and the North Fork beyond.... Read more
Welcome to Greenport, NY
A real boating community with a large protected harbor, the historic village of Greenport links the North Fork of Long Island with the South Fork vi... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.
Total Median Average Shelter Island, NY 4 $747,500 $715,000 home sale data for other nearby cities Amagansett, NY 7 $1,650,000 $2,551,286 Bay Point, NY 26 $742,500 $1,359,933 Bridgehampton, NY 4 $3,150,000 $3,009,375 Cutchogue, NY 13 $990,000 $998,768 E Hampton, NY 80 $730,000 $1,134,061 E Marion, NY 4 $412,500 $405,750 East Hampton, NY 80 $730,000 $1,134,061 East Marion, NY 4 $412,500 $405,750 Greenport, NY 4 $246,000 $254,250 Mattituck, NY 8 $374,500 $521,244 N Haven, NY 26 $742,500 $1,359,933 Nassau Point, NY 13 $990,000 $998,768 New Suffolk, NY 1 $425,000 $425,000 North Haven, NY 26 $742,500 $1,359,933 Orient, NY 2 $427,171 $427,171 Orient Point, NY 2 $427,171 $427,171 Peconic, NY 1 $250,000 $250,000 Pine Neck, NY 26 $742,500 $1,359,933 Sag Harbor, NY 26 $742,500 $1,359,933 Sagaponack, NY 6 $2,790,000 $3,667,167 Shelter Is, NY 4 $747,500 $715,000 Southold, NY 13 $440,000 $448,904 Wainscott, NY 3 $2,900,000 $2,350,000 Water Mill, NY 7 $2,530,000 $3,171,429 Watermill, NY 7 $2,530,000 $3,171,429
Show Statistics for: Amagansett, NY Aquebogue, NY Baiting Hollow, NY Bridgehampton, NY Calverton, NY Clinton, CT Cutchogue, NY East Hampton, NY East Marion, NY East Moriches, NY East Quogue, NY Eastport, NY Essex, CT Flanders, NY Greenport, NY Groton, CT Groton Long Point, CT Hampton Bays, NY Jamesport, NY Laurel, NY Manorville, NY Mattituck, NY Montauk, NY Mystic, CT New London, CT New Suffolk, NY Niantic, CT Noank, CT North Haven, NY Old Mystic, CT Orient, NY Peconic, NY Quioque, NY Quogue, NY Riverhead, NY Sag Harbor, NY Sagaponack, NY Shelter Island, NY Southampton, NY Southold, NY Stonington, CT Wading River, NY Wainscott, NY Watermill, NY Westhampton, NY Westhampton Beach, NY
Population Total Population 1,304 Population Density 239 Persons/Sq. Mile Female Population 662 Male Population 642 Population Change since 1990 ↑ 9% Increase Population Change since 2000 ↑ 6% Increase Colleges Nearest 2-Year Public College Gateway Community College Distance 35 miles Nearest 4-Year Public College Long Island U Friends Of World Distance 14 miles Households and Income Total Number of Households 536 Family Households 345 Average Family Size 3.18 Average Household Income $79,345 Median Household Income $56,052 Income Change since 1990 ↑ 350225% Increase Income Change since 2000 ↑ 29% Increase Crime Rates Compared to National Average The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk. Total Crime Risk 0.27 Crime Risk (County) 0.26 Personal Crime Risk (County) 0.29 Murder Crime Risk (County) 0.18 Rape Crime Risk (County) 0.25 Robbery Crime Risk (County) 0.25 Assault Crime Risk (County) 0.45 Property Crime Risk (County) 0.38 Burglary Crime Risk (County) 0.64 Larceny Crime Risk (County) 0.25 Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County) 0.43 Climate Average July High Temperature 80.1 °F Average January Low Temperature 23.7 °F Annual Precipitation 45.9 inches Air Pollution Index 105% of National Average Miscellaneous Sales Tax Rate 8.63% Nearest Airport Tweed-new Haven Distance 32 miles Nearest Major Sports Team Connecticut Sun Distance 32 miles
Show Schools in: Amagansett, NY Aquebogue, NY Baiting Hollow, NY Bay Point, NY Baycrest, NY Beach Hampton, NY Branford, CT Bridgehampton, NY Calverton, NY Centerbrook, CT Chester, CT Chesterfield, CT Clinton, CT Cutchogue, NY Deep River, CT E Hampton, NY E Moriches, NY E Quogue, NY East Haddam, CT East Hampton, NY East Lyme, CT East Moriches, NY East Quogue, NY Eastport, NY Flanders, NY Gales Ferry, CT Greenport, NY Groton, CT Groton Long Point, CT Guilford, CT Hampton Bays, NY Killingworth, CT Lords Point, CT Lyme, CT Madison, CT Manorville, NY Masons Island, CT Mattituck, NY Montauk, NY Montville, CT Mystic, CT N Branford, CT N Haven, NY Nassau Point, NY New London, CT New Suffolk, NY Niantic, CT Noank, CT North Branford, CT North Haven, NY Oakdale, CT Old Lyme, CT Old Saybrook, CT Orient, NY Orient Point, NY Pine Neck, NY Quaker Hill, CT Quioque, NY Quogue, NY Remsenburg, NY Riverhead, NY Sag Harbor, NY Sagaponack, NY Salem, CT Shelter Is, NY Shelter Island, NY Southampton, NY Southold, NY Speonk, NY Stonington, CT Uncasville, CT W Hampton bch, NY W Hampton beach, NY Wading River, NY Wainscott, NY Waterford, CT West Hampton beach, NY Westbrook, CT Westhampton Beach, NY Westhampton Dunes, NY Pin Schools to Map
Grade Levels: All Grade Levels Elementary School Middle School High School Other
Show Local Businesses in: Amagansett, NY Aquebogue, NY Baiting Hollow, NY Branford, CT Bridgehampton, NY Calverton, NY Centerbrook, CT Chester, CT Clinton, CT Cutchogue, NY Deep River, CT East Haddam, CT East Hampton, NY East Lyme, CT East Moriches, NY East Quogue, NY Essex, CT Gales Ferry, CT Greenport, NY Groton, CT Guilford, CT Haddam, CT Hampton Bays, NY Ivoryton, CT Jamesport, NY Madison, CT Manorville, NY Mattituck, NY Montauk, NY Mystic, CT New London, CT Niantic, CT North Branford, CT Old Lyme, CT Old Saybrook, CT Orient, NY Riverhead, NY Sag Harbor, NY Sagaponack, NY Salem, CT Shelter Island, NY Southampton, NY Southold, NY Speonk, NY Stonington, CT Uncasville, CT Wading River, NY Water Mill, NY Waterford, CT Westbrook, CT
ART AND MUSEUMS Havens House 16 S Ferry Rd BANKS Chase 48 N Ferry Rd EMERGENCY SERVICES Shelter Island Fire Dept State Rd Shelter Island Heights Fire Grand Ave Shelter Island Police 44 N Ferry Rd GOLF Shelter Island Country Club 26 Sunnyside Ave LIBRARIES - PUBLIC Shelter Island Public Library 114 State Rd PLACE OF WORSHIP St Marys Episcopal Church 26 Saint Marys Rd POST OFFICES Us Post Office 45 N Ferry Rd
Instant Cost of Living Comparison
For us to calculate a cost of living report, please provide us with the zip code where you currently live.
Enter Your Zip Code
Compare additional locations
2 Real Estate companies have been found with properties in or near Shelter Island
Click to search detailed community information for one or more ZIP codes in Shelter Island, New York. 
