Search for Homes:
Search
RELO® Home Search is your direct link to real estate experts, local information, and property listings from Leading Real Estate Companies of the World® members.
Scroll through the listing previews below to find the homes that interest you. They are sorted by price from low to high. You can refine your search if necessary or get more info about a property by clicking on its image.
Search Options
Location:
Min Price:
Max Price:
Bedrooms:
Bathrooms:
Property Types:
Single Family (72)
Rental (9)
Condo (2)
Land/Lot (2)
Multi Family (2)
Other (1)

About West Islip, NY

West Islip, NY is hamlet in the Town of Islip along Long Island’s Spectacular South Shore. It’s about 45 miles east of New York City, which is close enough to commute by car or train via the Long Island Railroad but far enough from the City’s hustle and bustle to enjoy the suburban lifestyle. About 35,000 people call the 4,000 acre hamlet home. West Islip’s geographic location is the first item on a long list of reasons why it is such a desirable place to live. To the south there is the Great South Bay which offers incredible year-round water views, including the Robert Moses Causeway adding some man-made elegance to the skyline. A short ride from West Islip on the Robert Moses Causeway will grant you access to Captree Boat Basin to satisfy the fisherman in you or if you prefer to be in the water yourself, a little further on the Causeway and you’ll be at Robert Moses State Park’s ocean beaches. But West Islip residents don’t have to cross bridges to get to the beach; they have access to West Islip’s own beach and marina.

Rich in history, records of West Islip’s earliest residents go back one thousand years to Native Americans known as the Secatogues. North of West Islip beach, historians unearthed an ancient burial ground, permitting them to reconstruct the village that once occupied the edge of the Great South Bay, Sumpwams, Trues and Willets Creeks. Proud of this heritage, many of West Islip’s streets got their names from the area’s Native American past. Jump ahead to colonial times. The La Grange Inn on Montauk Highway and Higbie Lane, currently operating as a restaurant and catering hall, was established in 1750 and General George Washington was said to have slept there before becoming president.

In the 1800s, West Islip was home to lavish estates. Among the notable families who owned these estates were the Magouns and Udalls. A main thoroughfare that runs through West Islip, Udall Road, is named for this family and the area where the Magoun family had their estate is known as Magoun Landing which today is one of the most luxurious and desirable areas on the entire South Shore.

From 1940 until the 1970s, West Islip developed into the suburban, family friendly area it is today. The West Islip school district is highly desirable. Not only does its students consistently score high on standardized academic exams but it has wonderful athletic programs and other extracurricular activities. There are a wide variety of homes in a wide variety of price ranges – from ranch and cape starter homes to luxurious waterfront estates.

There are also numerous community groups in West Islip that offer support, cultural enrichment and entertainment to its residents. They include the Chamber of Commerce, West Islip Beautification Society, American Legion, Chamber Orchestra Society and every September, the West Islip Bicentennial Committee sponsors a county fair.

West Islip truly offers something for everyone.

West Islip Chamber of Commerce: Stay up-to-date on all that West Islip has to offer in the marketplace and in the community at large on the West Islip Chamber of Commerce Website. Proud sponsors of the annual county fair since 1975, the West Islip Bicentennial Committee is dedicated to celebrating the West Islip way of life. West Islip Public Schools: Where education shines.
Contributed by:
Netter Real Estate
Learn about local communities and neighborhoods in New York
Welcome to Bay Shore, NY
Bay Shore is located on the Great South Bay of Long Island and is a large sprawling town. It was purchased from the Indians in 1701. The village is ... Read more
Welcome to North Babylon, NY
North Babylon, NY is a hamlet in the Town of Babylon and has an interesting history. Originally, North Babylon was comprised of a few farms. It the... Read more
Previous quarter's home sale average by city. Click city to view homes for sale.

Total
Sold

Median
Price

Average
Price

West Islip, NY38$332,500$375,934
home sale data for other nearby cities
Amity Harbor, NY47$295,000$272,656
Amityville, NY47$295,000$272,656
Babylon, NY108$311,787$306,779
Bay Shore, NY101$197,700$246,333
Bayberry Point, NY23$291,000$316,224
Brentwood, NY72$165,000$203,074
Brightwaters, NY6$534,785$539,512
Copiague, NY32$229,000$241,472
Deer Park, NY39$275,000$512,096
Deer Wells, NY25$428,000$558,591
East Farmingdale, NY33$307,000$319,121
East Islip, NY16$295,000$298,656
Heer Park, NY64$284,000$280,853
Islip, NY23$291,000$316,224
Lindenhurst, NY64$284,000$280,853
N Babylon, NY33$318,000$282,580
North Babylon, NY33$318,000$282,580
North Lindenhurst, NY64$284,000$280,853
Oak Beach, NY16$442,000$481,469
W Babylon, NY59$273,000$272,941
W Islip, NY38$332,500$375,934
West Babylon, NY59$273,000$272,941
West Bay Shore, NY101$197,700$246,333
Wheatley Heights, NY27$150,000$169,535
Wyandanch, NY27$150,000$169,535
Show Statistics for:

Population

Total Population30,134
Population Density5,037 Persons/Sq. Mile
Female Population15,199
Male Population14,935
Population Change since 1990↑ 5% Increase
Population Change since 2000↑ 4% Increase

Colleges

Nearest 2-Year Public CollegeIsland Drafting And Tech Inst
Distance7 miles
Nearest 4-Year Public CollegeFive Towns College
Distance6 miles

Households and Income

Total Number of Households8,848
Family Households7,388
Average Family Size3.82
Average Household Income$123,005
Median Household Income$94,709
Income Change since 1990↑ 31682% Increase
Income Change since 2000↑ 25% Increase

Crime Rates Compared to National Average

The National Average is designated 1.0 - A value of 2.0 represents twice as much risk while a value of 0.5 represents half as much risk.
Total Crime Risk0.39
Crime Risk (County)0.26
Personal Crime Risk (County)0.29
Murder Crime Risk (County)0.18
Rape Crime Risk (County)0.25
Robbery Crime Risk (County)0.25
Assault Crime Risk (County)0.45
Property Crime Risk (County)0.38
Burglary Crime Risk (County)0.64
Larceny Crime Risk (County)0.25
Motor Vehicle Theft Risk (County)0.43

Climate

Average July High Temperature81.0 °F
Average January Low Temperature24.2 °F
Annual Precipitation43.0 inches
Air Pollution Index106% of National Average

Miscellaneous

Sales Tax Rate8.63%
Nearest AirportLong Island Macarthur
Distance12 miles
Nearest Major Sports TeamNew York Islanders
Distance15 miles
Show Schools in:
show school on mapPin Schools to Map
Filter by District:
Grade Levels:
pin all schools

Grades: 7 - 8

Beach Street Middle School17 Beach St
Udall Road Middle School900 Udall Rd

Grades: 9 - 12

St John The Baptist High School1170 Montauk Hwy
West Islip Senior High School1 Lions Path

Grades: K - 6

Bayview Elementary School165 Snedecor Ave
Manetuck Elementary School800 Van Buren Ave
Oquenock Elementary School425 Spruce Ave
Paul J Bellew Elementary School25 Higbie Ln
Paul Kirdahy Elementary School - Captree339 Snedecor Ave
Westbrook Elementary School350 Higbie Ln

Grades: Other

Our Lady Of Lourdes School44 Toomey Rd
Show Local Businesses in:

BANKS

Bank Of America540 Montauk Hwy
Capital One Bank450 Union Blvd
Chase251 Higbie Ln
Chemical Bank187 Sunrise Hwy
Citizens Bank400 Union Blvd
Mark T Raymond Agency Inc282 Higbie Ln # B

EMERGENCY SERVICES

West Islip Fire Dept127 Watts Pl
West Islip Fire Dept309 Union Blvd

HOSPITALS

Good Samaritan Health System1000 Montauk Hwy
Good Samaritan Medical Ctr1000 Montauk Hwy

LIBRARIES - PUBLIC

West Islip Public Library3 Higbie Ln

PLACE OF WORSHIP

Church Of Christ600 Montauk Hwy
South Shore Christian Church36 Bay Shore Rd
Westminster United Prsbytrn109 Udall Rd

POST OFFICES

Us Post Office480 Union Blvd

WATER ACTIVITIES

Casamento Park PoolMuncey Rd

Instant Cost of Living Comparison

For us to calculate a cost of living report, please provide us with the zip code where you currently live.
Enter Your Zip Code
Compare additional locations
3 Real Estate companies have been found with properties in or near West Islip
Laffey Fine Homes
12 offices | 550 associates
company profile
areas served
website provides: IDX, Mortgage Pre-Approval, Photos/Virtual Tours